Best Bread For Tea Sandwiches

As an Amazon Associate, Daisy Flour may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Let’s talk about the best bread for tea sandwiches (finger sandwiches). These small bites can be made with subtle, crisp flavors or bold, intense ingredients, which means that the bread used to make these sandwiches is critical. A tea sandwich must also be made and presented in a neat and tidy way according to tradition. This further increases the importance of the bread used to make them. This raises the question, what bread is best for tea sandwiches?

The best bread for tea sandwiches should be:

  • firm yet soft
  • easy to slice
  • have a thin crust
  • have a good flavor that goes well with strong and subtle flavors.
bread for tea sandwiches

Good bread for tea sandwiches includes white, sourdough, and rye. Pumpernickel is a modern tea sandwich favorite.

Several types of bread can be used to make tea sandwiches, but some stand out better than the rest. Let’s explore the best bread for making tea sandwiches based on the ingredients within the sandwich and how the sandwiches are shaped and presented.

The Best Bread For Tea Sandwiches

Tea sandwiches are ideal for bridal showers, baby showers, weddings, parties, family events, corporate functions, and even a light lunch at home. These sandwiches can be made with various ingredients, including cucumber, red onion, roasted chicken, smoked salmon, and cheese.

The variety of occasions that tea sandwiches are made for, combined with the range of ingredients used to make them, means that several types of bread are well-suited for making them.

Tea sandwiches should be made with bread that compliments the sandwich ingredients and fillings, but they should also use bread that can be shaped correctly and handle the small size of a finger sandwich without falling apart.

Tea sandwiches are usually buttered, cut into thin sections, and have the crusts removed. Only thin slices of bread are used for tea sandwiches, and it should not overwhelm the flavors of the fillings.

This means that good bread for tea sandwiches must be able to withstand being thinly sliced, must not have a thick crust, but be flavorful without overpowering the ingredients, versatile enough to be made into cucumber sandwiches as well as smoked salmon sandwiches, and it must be sturdy (like bread used for French toast) and soft simultaneously.

This is a lot to ask from a loaf of bread, but the good news is that several breads fit this criterion. Let’s identify the best bread to use for tea sandwiches.  

White Bread

White bread is the classic bread used for tea sandwiches and remains a favorite everywhere these sandwiches are popular.

While regular wheat bread can be made with various recipes, it is ideal because it is firm enough to be thinly sliced while being soft and fluffy in texture, with a thin crust.

This bread is usually baked in a rectangular loaf, producing square bread slices that are also beneficial for making tea sandwiches.

This bread is mild tasting, but it still tastes good and complements almost any ingredients used for tea sandwiches. White bread holds butter well, soaks in condiments well, and will never overpower even the most subtle flavors.

White bread is usually considered the best for tea sandwiches and is the traditional choice.

Healthy Whole Wheat Tea Sandwiches

Whole wheat bread is an excellent option for tea sandwiches as well. This bread shares some similarities to white bread, as it is easy to slice thinly, it is firm and soft, and it has a thin crust, but this bread has a more robust flavor that is complementary to many tea sandwich flavors.

This bread is ideal for roast chicken and pairs very well with cheeses, making it ideal for many tea sandwich recipes.

It is important to use this bread quickly when making tea sandwiches, as it does dry out quickly, but other than this quirk, it is an ideal bread for tea sandwiches.

whole wheat bread for tea sandwiches

Sourdough Bread Tea Sandwiches

Sourdough bread is a modern choice for tea sandwiches and is a delicious option for this type of finger food.

Sourdough is complementary to most cheeses, meats, and sauces used for tea sandwiches and has a tangy flavor that can make any sandwich delicious.

However, sourdough is not the best bread for finger sandwiches with gentle, mild flavors, such as cucumber or plain cheese. This bread is best used for stronger sandwich flavors and recipes.

Rye Bread

Rye is another modern tea sandwich favorite, as it is a robust bread that complements strong flavors such as smoked salmon. It can still be easily sliced thinly and will not fall apart when used with wetter ingredients.

Rye bread is delicious on its own and has a good flavor that can hold its own with almost any sandwich ingredients. It is best for tea sandwiches with intense and sharp flavors, or it must be muted with soft flavors such as cream cheese.

Tea Sandwiches with Pumpernickel Bread

Pumpernickel bread is a kind of sourdough-rye combination. This bread is made with rye flour and a sourdough starter, which makes it the best of both breads, and is considered by many to be the perfect tea sandwich bread.

Pumpernickel has a good flavor but is not so strong that it cannot be used with gentle flavors. This bread is firm but also soft and can be combined with strong flavors. It can be thinly sliced, shaped easily, and barely has a crust at all.

 This is among the best bread to make tea sandwiches, regardless of the ingredients.


Tea sandwiches are surprisingly particular, and not just any bread will do for this type of sandwich. Take the time to determine your ingredients and the types of sandwiches you want to make before choosing the bread, and choose the bread based on the sandwiches you want to make.

Use a bread that will complement the flavors you choose without overwhelming them, and be sure it can be thinly sliced, cut into fingers, and have the crust cut off easily. this bread will do well for tea sandwiches.